Redefining caste system in Kerala – Are you BPL or APL
June 8th, 2009
Kerala is famous for its caste system. It was so horrible that even someone from India (Swami Vivekananda) called it the "lunatic asylum". Exposure to other cultures and rapid communication mechanisms improved the situation in Kerala drastically.
Yet caste based divisions are still strong. There is a strong undercurrent of both caste based and religion based politics. Take an example – Sri Narayana Guru was a visionary who realized that caste system is a plague. He said "Jaathi chothikkaruthu, parayaruthu, chinthikkaruthu" (Don’t ask, don’t talk and don’t even think about caste). But it is unfortunate that even the organization he founded is now hijacked by people who wants to spread the caste plague in our state.
Now in addition to all the caste and religion based problems, our government has now been successful in introducing a new economic based caste system. Currently it falls into two categories – APL and BPL. APL means "Above Poverty Level" and BPL means "Below Poverty Level". Now there are even proposals to create additional categories such as WBPL (Way Below Poverty Level) and WAPL (Way Above Poverty Level). Now if you thought introducing such system will eclipse caste based systems, you are wrong. It has only increased the divisions further. Now you have APL Muslim and BPL Scheduled Tribe etc.
Obviously one of the primary mandates for a government is to help who are economically backward. But this has to be done in a sensible way and a practical way. In the case of APL/BPL the objective obviously should be that in next few years, we should have zero BPL families in the state. Unfortunately this is not what is happening. Every year, BPL numbers are only increasing. Businessmen and NRIs who earn lakhs of rupees per month are also included under BPL and are given so much benefits that the families in APL are being squeezed like anything.
Governments have been increasing all types of taxation. Electricity charges, water charges, building tax etc have registered 200% to 1000% increase in last few years. Government ensures that BPL families are excluded from these rises. Which in turn affects APL families more. It has reached such a stage that these subsidies and taxes have made the living conditions of a lot of APL families to the level of BPL families. So instead of achieving merit based social progress, government actions are in some aspects turning out more poor people at the same time making a section of people lazy.
Another problem is the ridiculous level that the issue of reservation has reached. Any developed society would remove all types of reservation other than those for the physically disabled or those in dire economic conditions. But in India, we are going in the opposite direction (For example, the creamy layer was increased to 4.5lakh rupees in Kerala. This is an unfair definition but there is even demand to increase it to 7.5lakhs!!!) The following is possible future scenario in India,
A businessman sets up an administrative office. He needs to recruit 10 people for his office. According to the law of 2012 (actual scenario could be worse in the sense that there would be no general merit quota), his staff must include (the scenario is tailored for the reservation system in Kerala),
- 30% women (This 30% should follow the below rules as well)
- 20% BPL Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe
- 3% APL Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe
- 20% BPL Other Backward Classes (On rotation basis)
- 7% APL Other Backward Classes (On rotation basis)
- 10% BPL Religious Minorities (Muslims etc.)
- 2% APL Religious Minorities (Muslims etc.)
- 7% BPL General Merit
- 1% APL General Merit
Reservation was adopted after independence to give all sections of society and equal opportunity. Reservation was time bound and was supposed to be removed within 10 years of independence. However, it has grown to a monster which in long term has the potential to destroy our country.
Click here to receive latest site updates in your email!
Related Entries
- Kerala celebrates May Day 2007
- Saddam and Kerala – What is the connection?
- Cheriyanad – India’s first litigation controlled Panchayat
- Read Malayalam bible online
- Kerala movie awards – where is my award?
June 8th, 2009 at 2:39 pm
Well, if this is going to continue the whole nation is going to turn into a lunatic asylum.
June 10th, 2009 at 7:57 pm
I also share d same views about reservation system.but un fortunatly in india minorities are united against the majority people..so our politicial parties are afraid to touch them.bjp is an exception but their ideas are too communal to vote for them.
June 18th, 2009 at 6:12 pm
സംവരണം – സ്റ്റഡി ക്ലാസ്സ് അഡ്മിഷന് തുടരുന്നു…
June 22nd, 2009 at 3:00 pm
“You cannot legislate the poor into prosperity by legislating the wealthy out of prosperity. What one person receives without working for, another person must work for without receiving. The government cannot give to anybody anything that the government does not first take from somebody else. When half of the people get the idea that they do not have to work because the other half is going to take care of them, and when the other half gets the idea that it does no good to work because somebody else is going to get what they work for, that my dear friend, is the beginning of the end of any nation. You cannot multiply wealth by dividing it.”
Adrian Rogers, 1931
July 23rd, 2009 at 3:58 pm
The people who are reaping the benefits of reservation will never raise their voice against it even if they think its unfair. And that group is a huge population of voters whom politicians have to please. Anyway we should keep atleast the private sector free of such unfair practices, because it is detrimental to the development of our country.